New York may be a great place to live, but it can be an expensive place to die. Now, thanks to some significant revisions to some of New York’s outdated tax laws, the State has become a more attractive place to die – at least from an estate tax planning perspective.
On April 1, 2014, the Executive Budget of 2014-2015 was signed into law and significantly altered the estate tax structure in New York.
Only 19 states, and the District of Columbia, currently impose estate tax levies, and New York is one of them. Prior to the new law, the exemption amount in New York was $1,000,000. So if you died before the new law was enacted and your estate was valued at more than $1,000,000, then any amount exceeding the exemption would be subject to an estate tax at a gradual tax rate that topped off at 16%.
While $1,000,000 may seem like a lot of money, inflation and the increase in home values in New York have made $1,000,000 a lower number than you may think. It has become more common for many New Yorkers to accumulate at least this amount throughout their lifetimes. The low estate tax exemption combined with the net-worth of many residents has made New York an expensive place to die.
For years, many wealthy New Yorkers have successfully avoided the estate tax issue by either migrating to other states with more favorable tax laws in their later years, or by implementing sophisticated estate plans.
At first glance, the Executive Budget of 2014-2015 seems to provide an incentive for wealthy New Yorkers to remain in the state toward the end of their lives, and thereby thwart the migration and reduce the need for Estate Tax planning. But if you take a closer look, the reform has some significant pitfalls.
The new law immediately increases the New York State estate tax exemption from $1,000,000 to $2,062,500, effective for those passing away on or after April 1, 2014. Thereafter, the exemption amount will increase gradually until January 1, 2019, when the New York exemption amount will be $5,740,000. The chart below provides the current and historic New York State estate tax rates.
New York Basic Exclusion Amount from Estate Tax
|Prior to the 2014-2015 NYS Budget||$1,000,000|
|April 1, 2014 – March 31, 2015||$2,062,500|
|April 1, 2015 – March 31, 2016||$3,125,000|
|April 1, 2016 – March 31, 2017||$4,187,500|
|April 1, 2017 – December 31, 2018||$5,250,000|
|On or after January 1, 2019||$5,740,000|
These increases will certainly help reduce or eliminate the New York State estate tax liability for those under the exemption level at the time of death.
For example, if Tom died on April 2, 2014, leaving an estate worth $2,000,000, under previous tax laws, his estate would have been subject to a $99,600 New York State estate tax liability. However, under the new tax law, his estate would be exempt from paying New York State estate taxes.
This increase means that New York now has the third highest estate tax exemption in the northeast, after New Hampshire (no estate tax – live free and die free), and Vermont ($2,750,000 estate tax exemption).
Despite the immediate exemption increase and gradual increase that will ultimately align the State exemption amount with the Federal Unified Gift and Estate Tax Credit in 2019, there are some serious traps with the new law. The most significant disadvantage is that it entirely eliminates the use of the New York estate tax exemption for estates that are valued at more than 5% of the exemption amount (105% of the estate tax exemption level). So, if you die with just 5% more than the exemption amount, the entire amount of your estate will be subject to the estate tax, not just the amount exceeding the exemption.
For example, let’s assume that instead of leaving an estate worth $5,512,500, Tom died on April 2, 2017 with an estate worth $5,512,500, ($5,250,500 x 105% = $5,512,500) his estate will be subject to an estate tax liability of $452,300. Tom’s estate would effectively be subject to the same amount of tax liability that it would have been under the old tax law.
In addition to this 5% cliff, New York’s top estate tax rate of 16% still exists under the new law.
Another significant issue with the new law is that, unlike the federal law, there is no portability provision allowing a surviving spouse to shelter double the exemption. This lack of continuity with the federal law will undoubtedly create a pitfall for married couples and that will need to be resolved through the use of sophisticated estate tax plans.
New York does not currently have a gift tax. This means that New Yorkers can reduce the value of their taxable estates by gifting the bulk of their assets during their lifetime without fear of any gift tax at the state level. The new law significantly alters this estate planning strategy, by creating a three-year look-back period.
Now, any gifts that are made within three years of a decedent’s death must be added back to the New York gross estate. The increase of the gross estate creates the potential for a New York estate tax liability, assuming the value of the estate is higher than the exemption amount. In effect, we now have a reverse gift tax in New York.
The good news is that only gifts made between April 1, 2014 and December 31, 2018 are subject to this look back period. Hence, if you intend to make gifts to reduce your potential estate tax liability now is the time to do it.
According to the New York State Tax Reform and Fairness Commission’s Final Report, the new law was intended to make New York a more competitive place to live in the later years of life, and hopefully thwart the migration of older residents. Time will tell how successful this reform is in meeting the State’s objectives.
With the increase in the New York estate tax exemption comes a real concern that there will be a significantly lower demand for sophisticated estate tax planning. Although the demand will certainly decrease given the higher exemption amount being phased in over the next few years, when you consider the 5% cliff, the lack of portability, the maximum tax rate of 16%, and the three-year look back period for gifts, it becomes apparent that many New York residents will continue to have their estates subject to New York State estate tax. Many will go without planning due to a lack of understanding the traps in this New York State estate tax reform. This is a mistake.
By Eric J. Einhart – Guest Blogger